Projecting HD in a SD world
by jim brodie on Aug 22, 2010 at 1:27:56 pm
I've just finished a project in 1080p and want to deliver it to a school district for showing from a laptop through a projector. No one knows what kind of projector they have but their PC laptops are current.
I've discovered that Mpeg Streamclip is way better than Sorensen Squeeze for encoding the files into WMVs. They look great (at 16,000 kbs) but will they project properly? I realize the projectors could be SVGA (800 x 600) or XGA (1024 x 768). What will be the best size to offer them that will meet the specs for both projector options.
Would my 1080p x 1920 file automatically resize within a SD projector?
Thank you in advance for your insights. I posted the same question in the corporate video forum.
there are 2 different questions involved:
Scaling is rocket science!
But MPEG Streamclip delivers the best software scaling I have discovered so far.
And I have tested ALL solutions over the last year from freeware to ultra high-end.
('best' according to the definition 'maximum sharpness at minimum aliasing')
I assume you are working on OSX (M100), so you need to use Episode or at least Flip4Mac to encode *.wmv
When you got best results in MPEG Streamclip I assume you had used Flip4Mac? Since it is a quicktime component it is irrelevant what quicktime capable application you use to encode. The question is how your chosen application handles pre-processing (de-interlacing, scaling, etc.)
Now to answer your question:
The player application will do all the required scaling for you in realtime (=quick&dirty) to deliver a correct image through VGA
So simply scale and encode 3 versions with MPEG Streamclip ( 1080p; 720p; SD ) and test what resolution looks best and plays well on the laptops through your player application.