Re: Marker info disappears! by Angelo Lorenzo on Dec 26, 2012 at 7:54:53 am
Lets say you have:
and you merge them and end up with an automatically named
Vid1.mov - merged
What you may not have noticed is that if you add a marker to the original clip in the bin (Vid1.mov in this example) is that you have access to read those markers and title/comments in the merged clip. This is assuming you have some kind of scratch audio on your original video which would allow you to log in this manner. Annoying but hardly a showstopper, and shouldn't really increase your workload or tun-around time.
Concerning XML and merged clips, I think CS6 fixes some issues. I was able to take an XML from Premiere with merged clips and relink it in Final Cut Pro 7 and everything relinked fine. Even right clicking the audio portion of clip in the timeline and selecting "reveal in finder" finds the proper audio source file. They're treated like nested timelines in the bin, but seem to be master clips in the timeline... weird translation but it works.
The one huge speedbump that still remains, if I recall correctly, is how Premiere handles multi-cam exports.
It is really quite a big setback when you're editing a documentary. Being able to organize material and tag clips and add descriptions is an absolute must. So yes, this is a major setback for my process.
Re: Marker info disappears! by Jessica Jones on May 15, 2014 at 2:02:19 pm
It's been a while since this thread and I was wondering if anyone has any news on this based on the many recent updates to premiere?
I just spent a number of hours logging in merged clips with the anticipation of making a paper edit, and now they are all gone. It just seems so strange to me that with the number of final cut 7 users now in premiere they wouldn't have better modified their marker system.
Would appreciate any advice on the matter! I shot an interview with my 7D and Zoom h4n, merged the clips in premiere and added markers. Thanks so much!
Re: Marker info disappears! by Mateo Hinojosa on May 15, 2014 at 7:55:12 pm
So I've come up with an alternative workaround system for using markers in cs6... it's not perfect, and I'm not sure it will directly address this issue, but perhaps it could dovetail with other solutions, and I think some will find it useful for working with this imperfect marker system. Especially when your project has media you want to use for multiple sequences and you want a durable marker note system.
Basically, it looks like this:
1. sync dslr vid & external audio in pluraleyes
2. import xml to premiere
3. place synced interview in a new sequence, which I name my master (I'm coming from FCP7, so I'm thinking of this secuence kind of like I used to think of my master clips)
4. now the synced interview can be marked up with sequence markers that are easily readable and editable, and the duration is quite easy to change with mouse-dragging. Additionally, you can zoom in and out of the sequence to see the detailed marker notes. And you can easily modify the audio by disabling camera audio, etc.
5. then, in order to take pieces of this interview for other sequences, I duplicate that sequence as a temporary scratch sequence, cut up those clips at the marker points and copy-paste them into other sequences. I then delete the scratch sequences so I won't start marking that on accident, instead of my master interview sequence.
I'm finding this actually has some advantages over FCP's system, since you can see all of the durations and edit them more easily, as well as read the whole thing in the timeline. I miss the overlays, as well as some other features of FCP, but alas, c'est la vie.
I'm just experimenting for the first time with this system, and so far it seems to work well, but I don't know about exporting xml, chapter marker conversions, etc. There may be implications down the line that I am not foreseeing, and feedback is quite welcome. Anything I'm missing?