Sorry, but absolutely no one can have a clue. Templates can be notoriously complex, making it almost impossible to diagnose without looking over your shoulder.
If the numbers were there BEFORE you swapped out pictures, look for a text layer above the picture. If the numbers appear AFTER you swap the pictures, look for an expression.
FYI: simple possession of a template does NOT guarantee success in AE, because the template makers assume you have prior AE knowledge, ranging anywhere from beginner to advanced skills. If there are instructions for the template, you'd better read them carefully.
KGAN (CBS) & KFXA (Fox) Cedar Rapids, IA