FORUMS: list search recent posts

Re: lens resolution

COW Forums : Cinematography

Respond to this post   •   Return to posts index   •   Read entire thread

Todd Terry
Re: lens resolution
on Apr 7, 2012 at 11:09:23 pm

I'll add to Angelo's excellent and very technical explanation with one that is very down to earth and completely non-technical.

It just comes down to degrees of "good" and "not as good."

For years and years manufacturers, Canon and others, basically made two "grades" of lenses... good ones, and crappy ones. The good ones had very high resolution and were used for cinematographic and still film applications. Note that I said still film. The poorer ones were the ones made for videographic applications.

The ones made for video typically didn't have particularly high resolution... because they didn't have to... they were already resolving greater than the sensor that was capturing the image, so it didn't matter. They only had to be so good.

The better lenses, made for 35mm motion picture film and 35mm (and other formats) of still film photography, had to resolve much higher because their shooting format could. No one has ever really accurately come up with an equivalent "K" designation of what the real resolution of a 35mm frame of real film is... but (depending on the exact filmstock) it's often speculated that the actual resolution is something like 22K, or even higher. Ergo, those lenses really have to resolve absolutely pin sharp. Put that video lens (which looks perfectly fine on a video camera) on a real film camera, and it would likely perform very poorly.

The video lenses were/are quite inexpensive because they don't have to be made to nearly he stringent tolerances that cine lenses do. That's why a set of even good video lenses might be only a few thousand bucks, whereas a new set of Cooke primes is $100,000+. The video lenses are made on an assembly line... whereas high-end cine lenses are hand assembled, tweaked, projector tested, and collimated within an inch of their lives.

The advent of video cameras that can shoot much higher resolutions have forced lens manufacturers to sort of re-brand and re-label their offerings, and some lenses that were previously offered only for cinematographic use and now labeled "digital cinema" or such, indicating they resolve great enough to high-res videographic work.

Those Canon cinema lenses will resolve just fine for 4K, 5K, RED, Alexa, or any high-res format. Including film (if they happen to have the right mount).


Todd Terry
Creative Director
Fantastic Plastic Entertainment, Inc.

Posts IndexRead Thread 

Current Message Thread:

© 2018 All Rights Reserved