APPLE FINAL CUT PRO: Apple Final Cut Pro X FCPX Debates FCP Legacy FCP Tutorials

Re: The Position Tool Does Not Disable Ripple Mode - Here's Why

COW Forums : Apple Final Cut Pro X Debates

Respond to this post   •   Return to posts index   •   Read entire thread

David Lawrence
Re: The Position Tool Does Not Disable Ripple Mode - Here's Why
on Oct 10, 2011 at 8:20:12 pm

[Steve Connor] "David, gap behaviour is perfectly logical and not a bug at all."

Watch the video again. Just lifting and dropping the gap with the Position Tool causes the the clip to the immediate right to be swallowed. Why? Because the timeline is rippling under the lifted gap. If the Position Tool automatically creates gaps when you move a clip object, why wouldn't it also create gaps when you move a gap object? To my mind, this is inconsistent behavior.

[Steve Connor] "It would be illogical for FCPX to have behaviour where when you move or edit a gap, another gap is created! "


[Steve Connor] "Not true, Shift delete deletes the clip and leaves a gap automatically..."

Sure, but technically shift-delete is replace with gap. It's the opposite of FCP7 but I can adapt -- not that big a deal.

[Steve Connor] " do not have to manage the gaps at all, you don't have to touch them, you don't have to create them."

I find this to be untrue. Gaps are objects. You have to deal with them. If you want to extend open space to the right of a gap, you have to trim forward from the gap tail. Something you could easily accomplish in FCP7 with T or TTT and a quick drag. Or Try applying a cross dissolve at the head of a clip. In FCP7 the dissolve begins at the head of the clip. In FCPX the dissolve centers between the gap and the clip. There's currently no easy way to start the cross dissolve at transition end.

I realize that FCPX provides other tools to accomplish the same goals. But as long as gaps are objects, you have to deal with them. My $.02

David Lawrence

Posts IndexRead Thread 

Current Message Thread:

© 2018 All Rights Reserved