FORUMS: list search recent posts

Re: The SuperApp? A current Smoke user's take...

COW Forums : Autodesk Smoke

Respond to this post   •   Return to posts index   •   Read entire thread

David Jahns
Re: The SuperApp? A current Smoke user's take...
on May 3, 2012 at 3:18:59 pm

Hi Robert - we seem to be on the same wavelength for lots of things lately, eh?

Regarding Smoke 2013 - I do think people would prefer an all-in-one solution. I think Autodesk's potential stumbling block with it that expectations are so high, and like you have said, there are many tools that do one specific thing very well, and I think people may be disappointed that Smoke doesn't do ALL of them better than anything else.

In my opinion that's a completley unrealistic expectation - the "everything tool" can't be the absolute best at everything - but it can be pretty damn good at everything, and I think Smoke is.

Is it a better compositing tool than Nuke?
Is it a better tracker than Mocha?
Is it better at Grading than Resolve?
Is it a better editor than Media Composer?

The answer is no to all of these things. And you have all of the time in the world, why not use the best tool for each task? But if I have a 4 hour client supervised session for a TV finish that has to do all of these things and create HD & SD tape masters before the Fedex pickup - it is absolutely the tool that I want to be using - even when it was $15k. (Yeah, we still deliver tape masters for broadcast. Solid, stable, difficult to screw it up on the other end - gamma shifts, field orders, etc.. we seen a lot of errors in the digital delivery pipeline)

Plus - who is really an expert at ALL of those tools? And is it justifyable to spend $10k on software for every room in a facility? And trying to configure a system with the right graphic cards, OS versions, Video cards, etc. that work for all of those apps? It's not easy.

Add all of this up and I think that's a big reason people are so psyched up about Smoke 2013. I just think there may be a bit of disappointment when the reality kicks in, and they realize it's not THE BEST at every one of its tasks. And, there's still quite a learning curve once you get into Action & Connect FX.

So it will be interesting to see the ratio of trial versions downloads to sales this fall.

Although I gotta say that for those people that get deep enough into using CONNECT FX, it will be hard to go back to life without it.

David Jahns
Joint Editorial
Portland, OR

Posts IndexRead Thread 

Current Message Thread:

© 2017 All Rights Reserved