So I watched Robert DuVall's 4-hour Western this week on cable.
I will stipulate up front I am not a big fan of the genre, but this director is well known for good work, and a good story is a good story, so I sat down with the wife (who is a HUGE DuVall and western fan) and watched it.
I found myself really distracted by the lighting. It looked like the D.P. was trying to make every frame look like a Thomas Kincaid painting, overly saturated, strong gold tints on everything all the time, which perhaps are supposed to make it seem old-timey or more romantic. Kind of flat lighting, without as much dynamic range as I would have expected. Where are the shadows? I wonder if it was shot in high def and converted? The night shots also grated on me; they seemed WAY over-lit and too steady considering the practical source is supposed to be a campfire or moonlight.
Am I the only one who felt like this? If so, maybe it's time to get a new TV, but I was hoping some others with a critical eye could comment.
I have not seen "Broken Trail" but I can tell you that the DP, Lloyd Ahern ASC, is a very good cameraman. He has many years of experience and has shot many westerns. I started working with Lloyd as a camera assistant on a film called "Wild Bill". Also Directed by Walter Hill. It is a beautiful movie. You should check it out.I have done many projects with Lloyd and I can tell you he does not make a practice out of flat lighting. I would say that he probably shot "Broken Trail" the way he normally does and the network pumped up the image for broadcast. This happens quite a bit. Not sure if it was shot on HD or film. I will check.
Flip Flop Films
Cinematography Forum Leader
[Mark Suszko]"The night shots also grated on me; they seemed WAY over-lit and too steady considering the practical source is supposed to be a campfire or moonlight."
Noticed the same thing. Can't say too much else about it because I changed the channel. It gave me that feeling of "this is probably great, and I wish I had the time and patience to sit down and just get into this, and maybe I will... some day."