It appears, at least from my initial investigation, that there is no practical method of getting content off a KiPro disk in a PC Windows environment in the field. By practical, I mean something even approaching "real-time" (hour for hour).
I tried a shareware application that claims to be able to read Mac disks ("HFSExplorer") but I could never even get it to see the KiPro disk. Now, I'm trying "MacDisk" but it is taking around 10 hours to transfer a ~100GB file (~90 min)
I am speaking from a field environment where I need to use a laptop to download the content between performances, etc. Perhaps a dedicated setup in an edit suite would be faster, but a 4-pin Firewire port into an average PC laptop just does not seem practical in the Real World. The Windows Explorer is telling me that I am getting 3-5 MB/sec. :-(
I am very much in agreement Richard. Through my testing, I have found “Mac Drive” ($50) to be the best program for our problem. I think it is slightly faster than “Mac Disk” but the issue is still there. Let me know if you come up with a solution, as there are many of us in the same boat.
Well I am trying a couple of alternatives.
The disk module for the KiPro has two I/O ports on it. A Firewire 800 connector, and a SATA connector (with a "Slimline" 6-pin power connector along side) This SATA data/power connector is the one that the KiPro recorder uses to talk to the hard drive module.
My first attempt was using a Firewire cable with the Firewire 800 big connector at the KiPro disk end, and the tiny 4-pin Firewire plug at the other end (which fits my Vaio laptop). I'm not sure whether it was the laptop or the mini-Firewire connection that was making things creep along at 3-5 Mb/sec, but it was intolerable.
I switched to my bigger desktop edit system (Intel Core2Quad Q9450 @ 2.66GHz) and I installed a "SIIG DP FireWire 800 PCI-32T" board ($60) and I used a Firewire 800 to 800 cable (which also provides power) The copy speed says "1.46MB/second" which is not even good enough to be pathetic and pitiful. It is downright ridiculous. What a colossal waste of time and $$
Then I also installed a simple "Slimline SATA to SATA Power/Data adapter" cable ($6 at my neighborhood computer parts shop) and it is running at 60-80MB/sec! This is clearly the method of choice, at least in my book. Just thought I should share the discovery in case anyone is interested.
The AJA Sales Department has been informed that there may be some specific settings that need to be adjusted if you are using FireWire devices (like the Ki Pro Storage Module) when operating under Windows 7.
1. Open "My Computer" or "Computer" from your (Start) Menu.
2. Right-click the external hard disk drive from the list and select "properties"
7. Click the "Hardware" tab.
8. Highlight the Ki Pro Storage Module from the drive list and click on "Properties".
9. Click on the “Policies” tab.
10. You will see two radio buttons - "Optimize for quick removal" and "optimize for performance".
11. If not selected, select "Optimize for performance" and click on "OK". If running Vista or Windows 7 also check "enable write caching on the disk".
12. Click on "OK" and exit.
AJA Video Systems
+1 (530) 274-2048 Intl.
(800) 251-4224 US
I have done exactly what you you are talking about in the past. I think I had to reboot each time I connected due to the eSata connection. It was a while ago though so things might have changed in that regard. I ended up getting a MacBook!
I have been reading forums as I am gearing up to build a big transfer/compression station for use on conventions where the client wants MP4 files, instead of a mountain of data.
My idea is to buy a couple Firewire 800 PCI Express cards and have a couple 4TB drives internally.
After reading around it seems that people are having the slow transfer problem with 64bit versions of Windows. One person mentioned that his 32bit Windows XP transferred to his firewire mini just fine, and yet on his Windows 7 x64, it dropped to the slow rates you experienced.
Just out of curiosity, do you have a 64bit OS running on your laptop?
I hope to be able to afford building this system soon. :-)