I'm in the early stages of a large project, adding keywords and other metadata to my clips.
I came up with the mind-bendingly genius idea to create a smart collection to show me clips that I haven't keyworded. FWIW, I let FCPX add folder structure keywords when I imported clips. My smart collection shows me clips that don't have any of my other keywords in them. It ignores the specific keywords associated with the directory structure.
My trouble now is how to conveniently populate those unmolested clips with keywords.
Ideal workflow: I'm in the 'no keywords added' smart collection. I select a handful of clips that deserve the same few keywords. I'd enter all of those keywords, press Enter, the clips would disappear (since they now no longer meet the smart collection criteria) and I move on to the next lot.
The trouble with this workflow is that I can only add a single keyword at a time before the clip(s) in question disappear from the smart collection (by virtue of having now having particular keywords in them).
The best way I can think of overcoming this is the select my clips from the smart collection, then change to a different collection/folder where I know they will show up (e.g. "All Video" or "Entire Library"), then I'm free to add metadata to my heart's content. Then return the smart collection for the next lot. The issue is I can't see how to change my folder/collection whilst retaining my selection of clips.
Perhaps I need to modify how my smart collection works, but it escapes me. Any clever people out there have any ideas?
Perhaps not elegant, but you could use a "preliminary" keyword first, like "meta_add". Add this keyword to your clip selection, then use a smart folder that shows only clips with keyword "meta_add" (as they've disappeared from your "not keyworded" smart folder). Now you're viewing just your new set of clips. Add more keywords. When you're done, select all the clips in "meta_add" smart folder, and delete the temp keyword "meta_add". This empties the "meta_add" smart folder and frees it up for your next set of clips.
You do yourself a discredit sir - that is a most elegant solution given that the software doesn't work in the way I want.
By way of homage, I'll use the exact keyword "meta_add".
If I took your logic further, I could add several layers such as "no_shot_type", which I later remove when I've populated shot types, which I wouldn't bother to do on my first pass. "No_Location", etc.
I've already got this implemented now. FWIW, I added "AA " before all of my utility keywords so they appear at the start of the keyword string. This makes it easy to delete them when no longer required.
You can Favorite all clips that don't have keywords.
Make a Smart Collection of Favorited clips.
Keyword clips in the Favorite Smart Collection. As you are done with a selection, perhaps after some number of keywords. Un Favorite them, controlling their disappearance from that Smart Collection.
In some respects it's a variation on Bob's suggestion but instead of using a "meta" keyword, you're using Favorite which has a very easy Un Favorite (un rate) option.
Thanks Craig, that's another very appealing workflow. The benefit of favourites, as you say, is it's SOOOO much simpler to remove the favourites tag. The obvious downside is that one can no longer use the 'favourite' as a rating. Personally, I haven't tagged many favourites yet in this project, but my intent is to be tagging some in these early passes.
A workaround that just occurred to me is to use favourites as you suggest, for my 'no keywords manually added' tag, and actually add a keyword called 'favourite' as a positive rating.
That 'favourite' keyword could remain forever, or, when the logging has been completed (i.e. no clips are tagged 'favourite' any longer), select all clips with the keyword 'favourite', tag them as favourites then kill the keyword.
The Bob and Mat No_Meta family of keywords, by contrast, has more control (e.g. No_Location versus No_ShotType), but is a bit slower to manage. Hmmm.
As yet another alternative, is there a good way to replicate my actual directory structure within FCPX? If so, then I could trash all the automated directory structure keywords and would be free to use the existing Keywords: Do Not Exist filter as Apple intended. Even if this is possible, Bob and Craig's solutions are great tricks in the bag that can be used in parallel for metadata filtering and control within the confines of the toolset.
If you're just using Favorites to help organize for Keywording, once you're done assigning keywords you can then un-rate all the clips and start using Favorites as you normally would with their new intent.