FORUMS: list search recent posts


COW Forums : TV & Movie Appreciation

<< PREVIOUS   •   VIEW ALL   •   PRINT   •   NEXT >>
Scott Roberts
on Dec 4, 2013 at 2:47:29 pm

A few times a year I go to what I like to call a "senior discount showing." One of those movies where I'll go to an 11 am screening of something, and the theater will still be 3/4ths sold out, and I'll be the youngest person there by thirty years. I guess it's because old people don't want those disrespectful youths being rowdy with all their cell phones and skateboards and sticking their tongues out and whatnot. I'm sure the 8 pm screening of an Alexander Payne film is like an orgy of people yelling, blasting rap music, and throwing eggs at the theater screen. Kids just can't handle the nuanced dialogue and deep character development, it turns them into animals! That's not to say that the 11 am screening is without its annoyances. As one of the people who doesn't need a hearing aid, I can get a good sampling of the sounds of the elderly. The mucus-filled coughs, the "HUH's?", the constant popcorn jangling (seriously 80% of old people buy popcorn). And Nebraska was an extra special senior discount showing, because it was a theater filled with old people watching a movie ABOUT old people. That's like some Inception levels of geriatric layering. ...Oldception? Ok, I'll see myself out.

Nebraska is about Woody Grant (Bruce Dern), an old man and father who has drank his life away. He still manages to keep his family, but with the cost of emotional distance. One day, he receives a letter in the mail saying he has won a million dollars in a sweepstakes, and he has to go claim his prize in Nebraska. His son David (Will Forte) immediately notices that it's a very obvious magazine subscription scam, but offers to drive his dad to Nebraska anyway, in order to give the guy something to live for, and also to get the bonding time with his father that he never had a chance to get before. Along the way, they stop at Woody's childhood town, and have an extended and hilarious family reunion.

The standout role in this film, for me, was that of Woody's wife and David's mother Kate, played by June Squibb. She was funny as hell. Normally I don't care for old person acting inappropriate-type humor, but she took it to a higher level. She transcended the usual Adam Sandler movie "Oooooo! I pooped my pants! (giant fart noise)" type old person humor, and instead went into "You see that guy? He tried to grab my boobs 40 years ago. Now let's go get dinner." type subtle old person humor. She has a type of honesty that I respect in old people. If you're so old that you feel you can say whatever you want, then she's doing it right. Hey, as long as she isn't the clichéd over-sexed grandma (also a Sandler movie staple), I'm happy. On a quick side note, Squibb also just had a borderline Emmy deserving guest performance on HBO's new show "Getting On" two days ago, in which she also played a brutally honest old bat. I think my new ranking of favorite old lady actresses now goes:

1. The grandma from Happy Gilmore (Sandler's only perfect use of a grandma)

2. Estelle Harris

3. June Squibb

4. Ellen Burstyn

5. Doris Roberts (NO RELATION)

Bruce Dern does a sufficient job for the role of Woody. He's not really given much dialogue, because the character isn't much of a talker, but he does a lot of noticeable acting through his expressions and body language. He does this thing where he sticks his tongue out right before he takes a drink of beer, and he did it every time, and I wasn't sure if it was something Dern chose to do with his character, or if that's just how he drinks beer in real life, but I couldn't UN-see it once I started noticing it. Anyway, I wouldn't hold out hope that he gets any acting awards for the role, but he plays "confused drunk grandpa" with slightly more realism than Johnny Knoxville did earlier this year. Will Forte (MacGruber) proves he actually has acting chops. Though, I *also* wouldn't go as far as to say that his work is mind-blowing either. But Forte and Dern fit the movie perfectly, and their (intentional lack of) chemistry is the main source of momentum for the film. Some of the other supporting roles went to Stacy Keach as the local jerk, and Bob Odenkirk as David's brother, who seemed like a good fit to be Will Forte's brother. Most of Woody's relatives and the local town folk were so genuinely boring and droll (in a good way) that it had me questioning whether they were even actors at all? And one of David's cousins, perhaps the funniest non-Squibb character in the film, was played by the (now obese) actor who played Buzz in the Home Alone movies. Woof! [breaks picture frame]

The aesthetic elephant in the room is the black and white cinematography. I personally didn't care for it. I also am not sure why it was done, other than to make the film stand out as *the* black and white movie of 2013? But the problem is, other than maybe a few scenic shots, the film isn't shot particularly brilliant in its use of the black and white. Now I'm not badmouthing the framing or anything like that, that was well done. Just the use of light and shadow. I mean, if you're gonna shoot black and white, then make it be an awesome high-contrast, deep black kind of thing, right? A lot of this film felt like it was just desaturated color footage. I *hope* that wasn't actually the case, because that would be a terrible idea; so if I assume that's not going on, then it was just kind of a poorly shot movie. Eh, weird choice.

The film also has a very slow pace, but it's clearly supposed to be slow, so I can't hold that against it. Besides, any issues I could have potentially had with the pacing were eradicated by the consistently good humor throughout. Alexander Payne has always been good at balancing drama with comedy, and he's getting closer and closer to perfecting the mixture. I got emotional at the end, but not overly emotional. It has a good payoff of a final sequence. I'd rank Nebraska well below Sideways and Election, but above The Descendants and About Schmidt. It's probably tied with Citizen Ruth. Alexander Payne's filmography kind of rules, just sayin'. At this point I'd say it's safe to recommend any of his movies to most people. Go see Nebraska. It's worth it. But go to an evening screening, as to not bother the hunched over wrinkled folk who don't want your young person stink all over them.

8 out of 10

Return to posts index

Kylee Peña
Re: Nebraska
on Dec 4, 2013 at 3:17:48 pm

I was looking into this film because I like slow dramas that make me feel bad about things, and I saw an article with Payne talking about the black and white. He said they did it in black and white because it seemed appropriate for the story. So because art.

I also read he hopes nobody sees it in color. It was a point of conflict, some wanted a color version for TV release or whatever. So unless they're going to colorize it, I'm guessing they shot in color.

That's kind of a bummer to me as well. If I'm making a black and white film, I think I would want that to be the only version that exists, right? For a number of reasons, the biggest of all being because that's the way you freakin' wanted it. But it sounds like maybe there wasn't necessarily a choice in the matter.

twitter: @kyl33t

Return to posts index

Tim Wilson
Re: Nebraska
on Dec 4, 2013 at 9:29:45 pm

[Kylee Wall] "I'm guessing they shot in color."

This is more common than not. The Artist was shot in color too.

(Not that "common" is the right word for this.)

I was surprised, because it was shot on film, with the Pan-Arri 435 ES.

Turns out that the black and white stocks were all too sharp. :-) Not enough grain, so they got their grain by managing the DI conversion from color to b&w.

I don't know if Payne's evolution on this was the same as this, but I wouldn't be shocked.

Return to posts index

Scott Roberts
Re: Nebraska
on Dec 5, 2013 at 11:49:01 pm
Last Edited By Scott Roberts on Dec 5, 2013 at 11:49:30 pm

Hmmm... That just seems weird to me. I couldn't imagine getting the shadows you'd want in a black and white film while shooting in color and adjusting it in post... It certainly didn't work for Nebraska. The cinematography probably would have worked just as good (or better) if he shot the film in color, but with an intentional dull/yellowish tint. I don't know, I'm no cinemagraphotoomiterizor.

Return to posts index

Herb Sevush
Re: Nebraska
on Dec 6, 2013 at 3:54:53 pm

First of all the film was great, especially if you like Payne's films - it's a perfect compliment to "About Schmidt." The B&W was a match for the colorless affect of the entire Grant family as well as the whole mid western ethos that Payne sets his story in. The film would have looked better if it had been shot in something like tri-x - color to B&W conversions don't have the deep blacks and correct contrast, but it had a beautiful bleakness to it - the look reminded me both of Hud and Paper Moon. Like all B&W films it's a little unsettling at first, but after a few minutes you forget all about it.

Herb Sevush
Zebra Productions
nothin' attached to nothin'
"Deciding the spine is the process of editing" F. Bieberkopf

Return to posts index

Jeff Breuer
Re: Nebraska
on Dec 6, 2013 at 4:24:43 pm

Really looking forward to this film, thanks Scott! By the way, I watched The Artist in the exact same way and loved it. I have a friend whose favorite movie-going experience is watching Shrek 2 in a sold out Saturday matinee filled with kids. When you watch a movie with the target audience, it helps pull you in all the more further. Except when the kids are throwing Dots at your head and yelling "poo-poo" at their sister I suppose...or if you are watching Cheech & Chong and you just got out of Betty Ford...but I digress.

I think that if you are a director who is really into cinematography, a black and white film is just something you have to get out of your system at some point. Seriously, it's like taking two years of screenwriting classes and NOT writing a mafia flick. Coen Brothers, Soderbergh, Coppola, Burton, Spielberg, Woddy Allen...Carl Reiner...even Clooney! They all had to get it out of their system eventually. Even guys like Nolan and Aronofsky started out there. Got it out of their system early I suppose.

Return to posts index

<< PREVIOUS   •   VIEW ALL   •   PRINT   •   NEXT >>
© 2019 All Rights Reserved