FORUMS: list search recent posts

2012 Oscar Noms

COW Forums : TV & Movie Appreciation

<< PREVIOUS   •   VIEW ALL   •   PRINT   •   NEXT >>
Scott Roberts
2012 Oscar Noms
on Jan 24, 2012 at 3:24:26 pm

The Academy Award Nominations have been released:

Here are my thoughts:

-Overall, 2011 was a crappy year for film.

-This is one of the worst Best Picture categories in years. Four of the films (Tree of Life [awful], Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close, The Help, and War Horse) are various definitions of Oscar bait. Moneyball and Hugo were decent, but not great. Midnight in Paris was pretty good, but won’t win. It really is a race between The Artist and The Descendants, either of which I would be happy if they won. But the rest of the nominees are kind of wastes of nomination acknowledgement. No Girl With the Dragon Tattoo?

-Director category is fine, except for Terrence Malick, who IS a great director, but Tree of Life is a huge waste of time. David Fincher snub.

-Clooney has lock down on Best Actor. But a Fassbender snub for Shame. Much better than Gary Oldman in Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy.

-I hope the Academy wises up, and picks someone other than Meryl Streep for her comically lame impersonation (not performance) of Thatcher (that's based on the trailers, I will probably never see The Iron Lady in my life). And don't give it to Viola Davis for The Help. I thought she just moped around the whole movie and had an overly melodramatic scene at the end as her big moment. Crying shouldn't guarantee Oscar nominations, people. Maybe give it to Rooney Mara? The only person in this category who actually put work into her role?

-It’s awesome that Melissa McCarthy got nominated for Bridesmaids, which she actually has a chance of winning. But it will probably go to Octavia Spencer for The Help. I’d be cool with either, because they were both the best parts of their respective movies.

-I think it’s established that Christopher Plummer will win Best Supporting Actor for Beginners (which I still need to see), but it’s pretty cool that Jonah Hill got nominated for a performance that I didn’t think was even that Oscar worthy. Nice to know 21 Jump Street will have an Academy Award nominated actor in it. Nick Nolte for Warrior also pretty cool.

-Super disappointed that 50/50 didn’t get a Best Original Screenplay nomination (or any for that matter). I guess the Academy only has room for a few movies of genuine, non-manipulative emotion each year. Gotta make room for the cheese. This is a pretty interesting category. I’m sure Midnight in Paris will win, especially with also getting Best Picture and Director nominations. Interesting to see Bridesmaids get nominated. A scene involving pooping in a sink has finally made its way into an Academy Award nominated screenplay, kudos. But it was basically this year’s Hangover. I don’t mean that they are similar in plot or comedy style (which they kind of are in some ways, I guess), but more that they were both just that universally accepted R-rated comedy that EVERYBODY saw, and at the minimum thought was slightly above average. I’m surprised that the Academy finally caved into popular demand for a change. And while I think 50/50 is more genuine a movie than Bridesmaids (admit it, it fell into a handful of cliche comedy traps), I would like to see more movies LIKE Bridesmaids get nominated in the future. So to Bridesmaids getting a nomination, my official stance is: 50/50 GETS RELEASED ON BLU-RAY AND DVD TODAY, GO BUY/RENT IT!

-Alexander Payne should be picking up another Adapted Screenplay award.

-Rango should win Best Animated Feature, though I wouldn’t be surprised if one of the two foreign animated movies I’ve never heard of win. I’m just happy Adventures of Tintin didn’t get nominated.

-Drive and Harry Potter got some random technical award noms. I don’t know if that makes me happy, or angry that this means the Academy actually knows of their existence, but didn’t give them more recognition. Otherwise it could have been like “Oh, they must not have seen it, that’s why they didn’t give it any credit”. That’s what I think happened to 50/50. If you can’t tell, I’m super bitter about 50/50.

-Andy Serkis / Rise of the Apes for Best Visual effects? I hope Transformers doesn’t steal this, just because I thought Rise was a way better movie.

-No Project Nim for documentary? I thought everyone loved that film? The only two documentaries I saw this year were the Morgan Spurlock one, and Knuckle (about Irish bareknuckle boxing, which was awesome). I plan on watching Senna this week, but that's totally unrelated as it didn't get nominated either.

-Didn't see any of the forgeign language films... <--- uncultured American over here.

-Man or Muppet WILL win Best Original song. That is so incredibly awesome. In fact, the Best Song category is my favorite category this year BY FAR. Just two songs, one obvious winner, then some other random song from Rio. But I especially like it because it casually points out how crappy the Golden Globes' Best Song nominees list was.

Return to posts index

Jeff Breuer
Re: 2012 Oscar Noms
on Jan 24, 2012 at 3:58:14 pm

I was about as satisfied as I could have expected to be with the noms. I try not to get my hopes up too much. Here are a few of my thoughts.

--I'm with you, 50/50 got snubbed, sad. Same with Ides of March. Should have received a Best Picture nod and several acting nods.

--If The Artist does not win Best Picture OR if Meryl Streep wins, I might cry.

--[Scott Roberts] "Man or Muppet WILL win Best Original song." Yes! [Scott Roberts] "because it casually points out how crappy the Golden Globes' list of Best Song nominees was." Madonna was not even nominated. Booya.

--Glad to see some love for Midnight in Paris. I know it was a long shot but I was really hoping to see Owen Wilson with a nod.

--"A Separation" is a slam dunk for Best Foreign film, interesting to see it up for best O. Screenplay too. On the Foreign front it was also surprising to see Demián Bichir in "A Better Life." Haven't seen it, but it seems Oscars like to throw in a surprise from a foreign actor since Roberto Benigni won for Life is Beautiful.

Return to posts index

Scott Roberts
Re: 2012 Oscar Noms
on Jan 24, 2012 at 5:31:42 pm

[Jeff Breuer] "If The Artist does not win Best Picture OR if Meryl Streep wins, I might cry."

There's good potential for both of those things to happen... Tear inducing indeed. While I wouldn't really mind if The Descendants won, and I'd much rather have The Artist win, I fear that The Artist may start to get written off as something of a gimmick in the voter's minds. Which isn't actually the case. Plus, Descendants is more "Oscary" than The Artist. The Academy don't take too kindly to experimental or risky movies in that there Best Picture category...

Also, I didn't realize it initially, but someone at UPROXX pointed it out: Jim Rash (Dean Pelton from Community) co-wrote the Oscar nominated screenplay for The Descendants. Which means Rash has a good chance of leaving the building with a statuette. I hope they touch upon this in some way when Community starts back up. (walks in study room painted in gold from head-to-toe) "Congrats to the DEANscendants on their Oscar win!"

Return to posts index

Scott Roberts
Re: 2012 Oscar Noms
on Jan 24, 2012 at 9:53:09 pm

I was just thinking about it, I often get negative about the Oscars because the snub the crap out of most things I like, but there are actually some pretty cool nominees this year.

Just for fun, I made a quick collage of some of the interesting nominees, in past or present roles. Please don't over think my 6 minutes of work (most time spent finding pictures on Google, take that SOPA!).

<a href=''><img src='//' border='0'></a>

Return to posts index

<< PREVIOUS   •   VIEW ALL   •   PRINT   •   NEXT >>
© 2019 All Rights Reserved