Does anyone have an update to this issue? I've got a ProRes422 1080 29.97 HOUR LONG show that I've tried a few dozen paths to make look good on a DVD. Compressor and BitVice have not solved the resizing issue. I really think the problem is not the encoding but the resizing.
I'm using the latest FCP Studio and Snow Leopard. I do have a Kona LHi card, but my only output would be to DVCAM and making that round trip seems cumbersome.
Any ideas will me greatly appreciated.
You could also try MPEGStreamclip from Squared5 software. High quality scaler - we've been doing all our HD to SD scaling through it because it looks much better than either FCP or Compressor's scalers and it runs pretty quickly. Easier to get in / out of than Motion (for us, anyway) and does batch lists. And it's free.
It's good. I downscaled it using Streamclip (using Apple FCP Uncompressed 10-bit 4:2:2 codec, lower field, Better Downscaling) and then compressed it with BitVice and it's the first acceptable MPEG2 I've seen. Much better than downscaling in Motion.
I'm going to do a few more tests - next checking "Deinterlace Video" and will report.
After all the help I've gotten from this forum, I'm compelled to report on the results of my week of testing to get a decent MPEG2 file for DVD from a 1080 ProRes422 sequence in FCP.
"Send to Compressor" just doesn't work. As you've probably read, FCP is running in the background during this process and "unexpectedly quits" with longer timelines. And, it is painfully slow - much slower than exporting a self-contained QT movie and dropping it into Compressor. Either way, the results are very poor. Compressor cannot handle the downscaling from 1080 to 720.
My next attempt was BitVice. Here again, the downscale was the problem. So, I did a two-step and downscaled using Streamclip and compressed with BitVice. It was better, but far from good enough.
So, I did a test with Sorenson Squeeze 6. Finally, an MPEG2 that, when burned to a DVD in DVDSP, did justice to the gorgeous footage in this show. It's expensive software, but what good is a DVD with lousy images?
Now, I saw that the Squeeze I paid $799 for last week is on sale for $599. If hadn't been so desperate under a deadline... One slight issue with Sorenson is that Tech Support is poor to non-existent.
I hope somebody finds this info helpful and saves themselves 20-30 DVDs playing test pilot.
Many thanks for reporting back to the forum. It's really appreciated.
[Anthony Koelker]""Send to Compressor" just doesn't work"
It does. just not all the time for all people. It always works for me, but I choose not to use that method.
[Anthony Koelker]"Compressor cannot handle the downscaling from 1080 to 720. "
It can, very well in fact. (Tip: always use the 'Best' setting in frame controls)
[Anthony Koelker]"So, I did a test with Sorenson Squeeze 6. Finally, an MPEG2 that, when burned to a DVD in DVDSP, did justice to the gorgeous footage in this show. It's expensive software, but what good is a DVD with lousy images? "
MPEGStreamClip is just fast, not better. Squeeze: Expensive! Are you joking?
[Anthony Koelker]"Now, I saw that the Squeeze I paid $799 for last week is on sale for $599. If hadn't been so desperate under a deadline... One slight issue with Sorenson is that Tech Support is poor to non-existent. "
So you think that a company that licences a whole bunch of codecs and formats, pays developers to update it and sells it for $599 can afford to have support staff sitting there waiting for the phone to ring?! They can't be making more than a few dollars on each licence they sell.
How come you didn't try out Episode? IMO, a mile ahead of Squeeze.
Sent from my iPad Nano.