You could hand write your titles with something that creates a thick scratched look, with good contrast and then photograph it.
On white paper a black pen with multiple strokes on each letter or perhaps some charcoal might work well.
Then you just need to invert the photographs to get the white on black look and add a little glitchy flickering with Video Copilot’s twitch effect.
Graham Macfarlane - 3D visualisation and VFX
3D Studio Max | Vray | Pflow | PhoenixFD | After effects | Mocha