Difference in transitions on different hardware
I've been building a simple dvd in Encore cs4, and have added some transitions i made in after effects. I have two menus (chapters & contestants), that have two pages each. I have added a transition between the pages in both. On the mainmenu I have a moving background as well.
When I preview this DVD, it doesn't work at all, but after browsing around this forum, I guess the preview mode is not to be trusted.
Then I tested this on 4 different DVD-players, and practically got 5 different results. My test systems was: PS3, Toshiba HD-DVD, United DVD Player (cheap), Samsung DVD Player (decent), Pioneer DVD Player (good).
I got very different results. On some systems, the dvd goes to black for a second after each transition and after the background-video ends on the main menu, on others it freezed the last frame for a second (which is the optimal solution), on most players they freezed the transition in the contestant menus 10-15 frames before the end, and then jumped directly to the menu. Nothing smooth about that. It didn't do it on the ones that showed a black frame though.
All these inconsistencies annoy the hell out of me, but is there really anything I can do?
I also tested a DVD I made in DVD Studio Pro, which also had transitions, and got different results than from the Encore DVD on the various players.
For example I tested my Encore DVD on a PS3, and it had the black holes after transitions, but didn't have the 10-15 frames freeze. However it played the DVD Studio Pro transitions without any problems (though on the Pioneer it did show black after the transitions).
I've read about using a menu with a motion background as a transition, but is that really more efficient than using Encores built-in transition tab?
In the end I propably just have to accept, that no player will behave the same.
Unless of course you have a genius solution?
I created 50 frames transistions between the menus, I encoded the transistions at 7CBR, 2M/12N frame setting.
When I built the project to a folder and viewed it all the transistions looked fine, when I burnt the project to a DVD+R9 things went pair shaped, playback on DVD players varied.
1) PS3: Full frame black flash before the transistion settled back into the menu on half of the transistion. (3 fine, 3 black flash)
2) Midrange Sony player, same as PS3
3) Bargain basement DVD player, played all transistion fine.
I bumped into this problem when I first started using CS4 and read somewhere on this forum that the length of your transistion has to be evenly divisible by your m-frame setting, which solved the problem then.
Any ideas why some worked and some didn't? all exactly the same duration.
It must be a CS4 bug, this problem never reared it ugly head in CS3, I've given up with transistion apart from fade to black in CS4.