| Using H4n on film set
• | | | |
 | Using H4n on film set
by David Watson on Aug 16, 2012 at 5:22:38 am |
I was doing some tests with the Zoom H4n and am not sure how to use it for what I need on a film set. I work on short films, and most of the time we only use a boom mic to record audio. But sometimes we use 1-2 lavs in addition to the boom. And this all needs to be recorded at 48KHz/24-bit. Well I guess it doesn't NEED to be, but I would prefer it over 44.1KHz/16-bit.
On the H4n, the 3 modes are Stereo/4Ch/MTR. MTR mode allows for mono wav files, as well as stereo, but it only records at 44.1KHz/16-bit. Stereo mode only allows to record up to 96KHz/24-bit, but it only allows for stereo wav files. This isn't a problem when using only one mono input (ie, boom). In this case the audio is recorded onto both the LR channels of the wav. I can just strip out one channel or even work with a stereo file. The problem arises when using two mono inputs (boom + lav). The audio from each input is mixed together, and then duplicated to both the LR channels. So I don't think I can work on just the boom audio alone or just the lav audio alone. 4Ch mode isn't any better because it creates two stereo files from the two inputs and the two built-in mics.
So does this mean that I am forced to record one mic input at a time if I want to record in 48KHz/24-bit, or record in 44.1KHz/16-bit if I want to record multiple mics together?
David H. Watson
dEhiN Entertainment
| | | | |
• | | | |  | Re: Using H4n on film set by Brian Reynolds on Aug 16, 2012 at 10:54:44 am |
First question is..... How familiar are you with the H4n and have you done much work with it?
The H4n is a good recorder but it should NOT regarded as a 'Professional' recorder, yes it can deliver good results if used with care.
Are you intending to actively ride the audio levels (if so how are you going to do it?)or are you going to use it as a set and forget recorder?
| | | | |
• | | | |  | Re: Using H4n on film set by David Watson on Aug 16, 2012 at 11:17:53 am |
Hi Brian, I'm not familiar with it at all, and have done no work on it. A volunteer film group I'm part of purchased it to try and get better audio than using the built-in mics on DSLRs. In the past the group used to also rent equipment when using pro cameras (like the RED camera). But they recently purchased the H4n and a boom + pole + headphones (Sennheiser HD 280).
I don't foresee actively riding the audio levels, but I also don't plan to just set and forget. I plan to have a separate boom operator so I can monitor the recording levels. I know most of the time on a film set a boom mic will suffice alone to capture the audio. But I'm wondering if it's possible, and if so how, to record more than one mic input (ie, boom + 1 lav) and record each separately - either as separate mono wav files, or one stereo wav file with each mic input on each LR channel.
David H. Watson
dEhiN Entertainment
| | | | |
• | | | |  | Re: Using H4n on film set by Peter Groom on Aug 16, 2012 at 9:13:05 pm |
h4n is really a 2 track recorder, both iputs on the rear xlrs/ jacks. if you have more surces you must either mix, cross jack or use 2 recorders.
i really would suggest you feed everything throug a f ield mixer and then to the recorders.
DONT allow audio to look after itself. It wont and will all go pear shaped. YOU MUST give it 100% attention. Let the pix loo after themselves.
Peter
Post Production Dubbing Mixer
| | | | |
• | | | |  | Re: Using H4n on film set by Brian Reynolds on Aug 16, 2012 at 11:37:05 pm |
David you mentioned... "I don't foresee actively riding the audio levels, but I also don't plan to just set and forget. I plan to have a separate boom operator so I can monitor the recording levels. I know most of the time on a film set a boom mic will suffice alone to capture the audio. But I'm wondering if it's possible, and if so how, to record more than one mic input (ie, boom + 1 lav) and record each separately - either as separate mono wav files, or one stereo wav file with each mic input on each LR channel"
Is the boom operator also monitoring the sound with headphones?..... I hope so, as a microphone sort of pointed in the right direction is like using a camera pointed in the right direction WITHOUT a viewfinder it might sort of work but very unlikely do give the desired results.
As mentioned the H4n should be regarded as a 2 track recorder if this doesn't suit the shoot you need to change the way you do things.
| | | | |
• | | | |  | Re: Using H4n on film set by David Watson on Aug 18, 2012 at 12:00:40 am |
So typically both the sound recordist and the boom operator both monitor levels? I guess that makes sense. If there's only one pair of headphones, what about self-booming? Is this feasible?
As for the H4n being a 2-track recorder, that should be fine for the shoots coming up. What I'm trying to figure out is whether it's possible to have 2 inputs recorded at 48KHz/24-bit on separate channels or wav files?
Or perhaps I should pose a new question: in music production, every single input is recorded on a separate track, regardless of what samplerate you use. I assumed the same should be for audio production on a film set. But someone mentioned above about using a field mixer if I have multiple inputs. But wouldn't this mean I am mixing on set and saving a mix of the inputs to one track? Is this the way audio for film is usually done? I know that generally the boom captures all audio, but what about when you have 1 or 2 principal actors specifically mic'd?
David H. Watson
dEhiN Entertainment
| | | | |
• | | | |  | Re: Using H4n on film set by Brian Reynolds on Aug 18, 2012 at 1:11:52 am |
So typically both the sound recordist and the boom operator both monitor levels? I guess that makes sense. If there's only one pair of headphones, what about self-booming? Is this feasible?
Yes they both need to have headphones BUT for different reasons.. the boom op is concerned about the positioning of the microphone and achieving the best sound he can get and the recordist is concerned about getting it on to the recorder and even more importantly what its like coming off the recorder. Yes for low budget productions you can self boom, and that's what most TV sound recordist do, have a mixer over the shoulder to keep an eye on the levels and hold the boom pole themselves.
Here is a setup I have used on a couple of shoots...
As for the H4n being a 2-track recorder, that should be fine for the shoots coming up. What I'm trying to figure out is whether it's possible to have 2 inputs recorded at 48KHz/24-bit on separate channels or wav files?
Yes the H4n will do that.
Or perhaps I should pose a new question: in music production, every single input is recorded on a separate track, regardless of what samplerate you use. I assumed the same should be for audio production on a film set. But someone mentioned above about using a field mixer if I have multiple inputs. But wouldn't this mean I am mixing on set and saving a mix of the inputs to one track? Is this the way audio for film is usually done? I know that generally the boom captures all audio, but what about when you have 1 or 2 principal actors specifically mic'd?
If you want to put things on separate tracks the H4n is good for 2 tracks, If you insist on recording the 2 radio mics to seperate tracks you may need to use a second H4n unit for the purpose OR there other machines around that will do more / and better such as the Roland R44 or Tascam DR680 as well as the Sound Devices range of recorders, the film industry standard is the SD788t, there are many other makes around also but the H4n is just the first baby step in film sound recording.
| | | | |
• | | | |  | Re: Using H4n on film set by David Watson on Aug 18, 2012 at 1:27:40 am |
Hi Brian, you mentioned that the H4n is good for 2 tracks at 48KHz/24-bit. But I can't figure out how to set it up. I read the manual plus did several tests myself. I know with MTR mode, I can have 2 inputs recorded to two different tracks (each track being saved as a mono wav file), but this is only at 44.1KHz/16-bit. And I know with Stereo mode, I can have 2 inputs recorded at 48KHz/24-bit but to one track (an interleaved stereo wav file). I guess what I want is a split-stereo wav file or 2 mono wav files at 48KHz/24-bit. How do I set this up on the H4n?
Also what is typically done with film audio - a mixdown of all dialogue or separate tracks for each mic?
David H. Watson
dEhiN Entertainment
| | | | |
• | | | |  | Re: Using H4n on film set by Brian Reynolds on Aug 18, 2012 at 1:53:57 am |
Record in 'Stereo' mode. (that is the most desirable recording method used on film / video shoots)
In post production these 2 tracks will then be regarded as separate tracks.
Forget 4 CH mode (unless you get custom cables made) and MTR is used for music production and is of little use on a film set.
The set up details are on page 51 of the manual. "1-03 Setting / Recording: Recording Format"
There is NOT a typical shoot... every job / location has its own needs and no one thing will solve the problems, you need to work through each one step by step.
Just like a fireman every fire is different with different problems and locations but they all have a common factor....
A location sound recordist is the same.... but with sound
| | | | |
• | | | |  | Re: Using H4n on film set by David Watson on Aug 18, 2012 at 2:05:14 am |
Hi Brian, thank you for your help. I figured out the problem - I had set Mono Mix to on, forgotten about it, and then had done my test. I set it to off, and re-tested and everything worked fine.
David H. Watson
dEhiN Entertainment
| | | | |
| |
|