Troy.. you are making too much of this
1. I answered his question first off... with a solution (one that a web or help search would have found). I did nto make fun of him or criticize hsi lack of knowledge. Simply stated the answer in three letters: PNG.
2. I teach college students as well, and have plenty of patience for them. I encourage them how to use the Cow, but also teach them how to use help, search posts, etc.
3. It is PERFECTLY clear that this individual did not use Help, as their are several answers screaming from the Help menus (form Export Transparent Image, to all of the How Tos, to just launching help and typing in JPEG).
4. My comment to you was not critizing you. Your information was accurate, but I was trying to point out, that typing such a througough answer only further disables someone who seems unable to perform even a basic search,
5. When a user joins, there is infor about Creative Calf and what the Cow is for (a detailed description of what more signal less noise means)
6. I do not laud my 'books' over people.... I write them to help people. But I am disspointed in how lazy many people are in typing questions to forums that could be found in less than 15 seconds on their own computer.
7. As a forum host, I am supposed to keep the forum on topic and make sure that the level of professionalism is maintained. By professionalism I mean the level of user experience. The Calf exists for just this sort of questions, as does online help.
Usually I avoid responding to these sorts of questions, perhaps I shoudl have done so here as well.
Again, not trying to isnult you or anything else.. just trying to get this individual to learn how to fend for themselves. I complemeneted your kindness, made a request with the word please, and explained my reasons.
You are free to disagree with me... but I'm just doing my job
Thanks
Richard M. Harrington, PMP
Author: Photoshop CS for Nonlinear Editors
Co-Author Final Cut Pro on the Spot, After Effects on the Spot, Broadcast Graphics on the Spot, and After Effects @ Work
Check out the new DVD: Photoshop CS: Essentials for Digital Video from
http://www.photoshopforvideo.com
edit - produce - direct -