Quality loss when burning to DVD
by Steve Shon on Aug 24, 2009 at 4:16:43 pm
I'm a new user to Final Cut Pro and DVD Studio Pro, and I'm having some problems with a DVD project I'm working on. If you can help me, I will be very grateful. I'm trying to burn a DVD from a project I created on FCP, and when I actually burn the DVD, the image quality is very low, although when I watch previews of the MPEG-2 I'm burning onto DVD, the image quality is fine.
I created a project on Final Cut Pro. The entire timeline is 29 minutes, 9;25 seconds long. When I was done editing it together, I selected "export using compressor". In the compressor, I used the following setting: DVD Best Quality 90 minutes. This produced an AC3 Audio file (40.1 MB) and an MPEG-2 file (1.26 GB).
I then went to DVD Studio Pro. Using the graphical interface, I dragged and dropped the MPEG-2 and the AC3 file into Track 1, and hit "burn". The resulting DVD had a drastic drop in image quality. Things that had been still frames in Final Cut Pro...now, the image was bouncing/vibrating slightly on screen. Blocks of light blue color or image jagging also interrupted the image. However, this only occurred in items that had been still frames on FCP (not sure if that's relevant, but if it might be, I'm saying it). All other video...people talking normally, etc....was fine, until ten minutes into the video, when the quality of the image began to toggle back and forth...every half a second, the image would go blurry; half a second later, it would be back to normal.
I used the DVD SP "simulation" to see if the problem was in the MPEG-2. The MPEG-2 was fine. I went into my Mac's finder, double-clicked on the MPEG-2 file name, which opened the file in MPEG Streamclip 1.9.2...and in that, the MPEG-2 played fine, too.
I searched these forums and found suggestions to (a) convert from FCP file to DVD SP on Compressor, and (b) to check DVD SP's settings. I went to DVD SP's file, preferences, and went to "encoding". The settings were as follows:
Aspect Ratio: 4:3
Start: 00:00:00:00 (drop frame box unchecked)
Field Order: Auto
Mode: One Pass VBR
Bit rate: 4.0 mbps
Max bit rate: 7.0 mbps
Motion Estimation: Better
I changed the Mode to Two Pass VBR, upped the Bit Rate to 7, and the Max Bit Rate to 9.0. I also changed "Motion Estimation" to "Best. Then I hit "apply", and then burned a DVD. Unfortunately, the setting changes have not affected the DVD quality. The new disc has all the same problems as the old one.
I would experiment more, except that I've already wasted four DVDs over the course of this project, and I thought I should probably ask for help before I wasted any more. Is there an adjustment to the settings I can make to make the DVD burn at acceptable quality? Or anything that I've done wrong here?
Re: Quality loss when burning to DVD by Michael Sacci on Aug 24, 2009 at 5:51:41 pm
[Steve Shon]"xcept that I've already wasted four DVDs"what's that $1.20 worth of disc?
This gets asked and answered about weekly on this forum. [Steve Shon]"bouncing/vibrating slightly"
This most likely is a field order issue. Bitrate will never fix this. Now if you are not viewing the FCP timeline on an external monitor you have no idea where the problem is starting, therefore you don't no where it needs to be fixed.
What is you sequence settings in FCP? What codec is the footage?
The 1/2 second blur is the encoding. For short videos like this always use CBR (there are no already made presets for this) Set the bitrate to 6.5 Mbps, still make the audio ac3.
Simulator is not used to check the quality of an encode, it checks navigation only.
Re: Quality loss when burning to DVD by Dylan Lee on Jun 23, 2011 at 11:57:38 pm
I'm having a very similar problem (DVDSP burns a Compressor-made .m2v into a DVD of considerably decreased image quality), but the quality degradation comes in the form of pixellation and color saturation (it's a 90 minute feature, original codec DVCPRO 720p60). Would adjusting the field dominance also address these issues? Do these symptoms sound familiar?