Red skews give me pixels/aliasing
by Stefan Sonnabend
on
Nov 4, 2009 at 11:01:06 am
Hello fellow cows,
I've been using the XDCAM EX3 for quite some time now and just noticed some pretty ugly aliasing on red areas. I don't know if it's my profile setup as haven't had the time to change it yet, but will do next week.
I've uploaded a screenshot made for some work-in-progress x-mas decoration vids, where you can clearly see the aliasing effect on the skews of the red ribbon:
Re: Red skews give me pixels/aliasing by Stefan Sonnabend on Nov 4, 2009 at 12:51:15 pm
It's for a website and will be converted down to 592*333 @ 800kbits.
Nobody will see these errors, of course. But on top of that I'm archiving all the vids to 1280*720p25 in 10Mbits (h264).
To be honest, it's not really much of a problem to me, as no one will ever notice. It just started to bug me, because I couldn't quite figure out what's the problem behind it. Maybe it's the camera itself and EVERY single one has the same problem?!?!?
I have to admit, I'm not too much into that settings stuff :( When we got the camera I looked up some settings Philip Bloom suggested and defined them while checking out some other profiles I found on dvinfo.net until I found my settings suitable.
I shot the footage with 3300K, if I remember correctly. The lights we used were a couple of those Mettle Quarzlight 1000W with a softbox, which was similar to this one here: http://bilder.csn-24.biz/bild.php?ja=102870
The project I'm working in is a progressive one, of course.
------ HAHA ------
While I was writing this reply, I figured it was just Adobe Premiere, which shows the aliasing. I feel a bit embarassed now, I didn't think about that earlier :(
I'm gonna render some of that footage uncompressed in 1080p to find out if these issues are just visible inside of Premiere or afterwards in an external player as well.
Re: Red skews give me pixels/aliasing by Stefan Sonnabend on Nov 13, 2009 at 10:42:45 am
Well,
I rendered it in both uncompressed .MOV and (close to) uncompressed (>30 MBits) .M2V to see if the problem remains. And it does, unfortunately.
I even imported some HDV footage (1440x1080i) shot with a crappy mini dv cam and got the same result: There are no jags on the skews in the raw footage when I watch it with both Quicktime and VLC, but as soon as I imported the file to Premiere there is this ugly aliasing.
At first I had the Premiere project preset for XDCAM but that doesn't really matter much, I guess. Because I tried it without any preset as well, and it gave me the same result.
Currently I'm running Premiere 4.1, but I'm gonna update it to 4.2 now, to see if that problem remains. Oh, I'm on Mac OSX 10.5.8.