Creative COW SIGN IN :: SPONSORS :: ABOUT US :: CONTACT US
ADOBE AFTER EFFECTS: ForumAE BasicsAE ExpressionsTutorialsArticlesPodcastsMotion GraphicsTrainingCinema 4D

I just need to know if I'm doing this right or wrong

Cow Forums : Adobe After Effects
FAQ   •   VIEW POSTS   •   ADD A NEW POST   •   SEARCH   •   CHANGE FORUM
Return to Posts Index   •   Read Entire Thread   •   Reply To This Post


I just need to know if I'm doing this right or wrong
by mike kov on May 12, 2008 at 12:40:00 am

I'm creating some animation in AE CS3, all my work is created in Photoshop at the Pal Widescreen setting (I think 720x576 if I remember correctly).

Now what I wanted to create in terms of my output was a nice widescreen video, which I presumed was 16x9 so I selected that in my composition settings, as it was what I was lead to believe Pal Widescreen was.

When I imported my images and placed them in my comp, the images looked a little squashed but I toggled the little pixel aspect ration correction button underneath my comp window and it stretched it out to look exactly as I wanted, so I thought that my problem was solved.
When i came to render my video, I made sure everything was right (16x9 Widescreen in my output options) then after it had done rendering, I watched it in Quicktime and it just looked like a squashed 4x3. I Full Screen-ed it (I don't know why I thought this may help) but everything still looked terrible.

I have read everything related to pixel aspect ratio I can find in Adobe's LiveDocs site for AEcs3 and I also read the "understand pixel aspect ration" article that I found on the FAQ's page of this site's forum page (linked just below) and I hate to admit I don't feel that I understand it any better.

I changed my comp settings to Square pixel widescreen, after having read about it here: http://www.creativecow.net/articles/gerard_rick/pixel_madness/index.html
My pixel aspect ratio is now square pixels and my comp changed to the widescreen I wanted.

(Sorry if I'm providing too much detail but I want to make sure you know everything I did so I can be told at what stage I went wrong.)


I also read about interpreting footage, so I was smart enough to realise the images I had created in Photoshop for this project would be different to the composition settings I had now, so i interpreted the footage to the same as my comps (widescreen square pixel) and i rendered a few seconds of it just so i could get a watch of it in Quicktime and it is coming out widescreen EXACTLY as i wanted it, no longer the 'squashed to 4x3' screen it appeared to be before.

Have I done this correctly?
I'm not sure why I used Pal DV/ Widescreen, I think I got told in a workshop to always use it.



Also if anybody is feeling generous could they please explain the difference to me between square pixels and non square.
So far my understand is:

PAL D1/DV Widescreen = non square pixels, used for live video footage

PAL D1/DV Widescreen Square Pixels = square pixels (obviously), used for motion graphics?

I know there are several other's but for the time being all I need to know about are those two.


Thanks in advance to anybody willing to help.



Return to Posts Index   •   Read Entire Thread   •   Reply To This Post


Current Message Thread:




Note: If you are a registered user and you do not see your name and email in the two respective fields above, you may reset your account cookies by clicking here. Your post will not be accepted if the name and email provided above are not currently registered in our database.

Name
E-Mail Address
Subject
E-Mail me when someone responds
Just This Message   Entire Thread   None  


Message                Add Bold Tag To Message (JavaScript required)

To put any item inside this tag:

1. Highlight the desired text
2.Click this buttonAdd Italic Tag To Message (JavaScript required)

To put any item inside this tag:

1. Highlight the desired text
2.Click this buttonAdd Underline Tag To Message (JavaScript required)

To put any item inside this tag:

1. Highlight the desired text
2.Click this buttonAdd Image Link Tag To Message (JavaScript required)

To put any item inside this tag:

1. Highlight the desired text
2.Click this buttonAdd URL Link Tag To Message (JavaScript required)

To put any item inside this tag:

1. Highlight the desired text
2.Click this button

Note: The following characters are HTML command characters, and may cause parts of your post to disappear, if not used correctly: < > &. To include any portion of the post in your response, highlight the desired text and hit the "Q" key. For more on how to post, click here.


Add your message signature


 


Note: By clicking "Post Direct" button above, you are agreeing to the Creative Cow's Code of Conduct.



FORUMSLIBRARYPODCASTSBLOGSMAGAZINESERVICESNEWSLETTERSNEWSSTOREEVENTS

© CreativeCOW.net All rights are reserved.

[Top]