Creative COW SIGN IN :: SPONSORS :: ABOUT US :: CONTACT US
HDV FORMAT: HDV Format ForumTutorialsApple FCP ForumAdobe Premiere Pro ForumSony Vegas Forum

Intensity(Pro) vs CineForm

Cow Forums : HDV Format
VIEW POSTS   •   ADD A NEW POST   •   SEARCH   •   CHANGE FORUM
Respond to this post   •   Return to posts index   •   Read entire thread


Intensity(Pro) vs CineForm
by kylesway on Sep 3, 2007 at 10:27:51 am

Hi all

I'm currently evaluating my options for HDV editing (1080i50).
I have started w/ PPro2's native HDV mode. With about 7-8h
worth of footage in the bins and several sequences, it has
gone very instable, and I'd like to have the "live" output
back (What the FireWire preview gave me for DV). In order to
be "more editable" in AfterEffects etc I'd like to go to an
intermediate codec. As the RTX2 is somewhat out of my current
budget as it is reported to be very picky about the machine
thus requiring a specialized one, I came up with the following
options:
1) Blackmagic Intensity (Pro):
- gives me output to HDMI/Component
- has a mjpeg intermediate codec
2) CineForm AspectHD:
- no output to HDMI/Component
- wavelet based codec (better than mjpeg)

Some questions I have / areas I'd like to know your experiences
with:
- Can both of these codes be used by "all" applications that
deal with video? (eg. converters; I need to convert my
.m2t files to the new codec)
- quality of the mjpeg codec compared to using native hdv.
(HDV native requires me to go non-HDV from AfterEffects,
and I cannot get ProCoder Express to create an HDV clip
that plays back "in real time" in PPro2 (as opposed to
clips that come from the camera via firewire)
- does PPro2 maintain stability, responsiveness etc with
those solutions?
- any other experience I should factor in my decision?

Primarily, I want to be able to work with HDV in PPro like
I could with DV thru firewire. Ie I'd like to have realtime
output to video projector / tv at least when rendered (not
export to tape which fails w/o message in my hdv project
right now). And I want to use a codec that works well with
AfterEffects. I cannot go uncompressed at the moment.

Hope this all makes sense, thanks a lot for your input!

-- Kyle


Respond to this post   •   Return to posts index   •   Read entire thread


Current Message Thread:




Note: If you are a registered user please click here to login before posting.

Your post will not be accepted if your name and email address are not registered in our database. Click here if you do not have an account.

Name
E-Mail Address
Subject
E-Mail me when someone responds
Just This Message   Entire Thread   None  

Message:



Note: The following are HTML characters and may cause parts of your post to disappear if not used correctly: < > &
To include any portion of the post in your response, highlight the desired text and hit the "Q" key. Read more...



Add your message signature


 


Note: By clicking "Post Direct" button above, you are agreeing to the Creative Cow's Code of Conduct.



FORUMSTUTORIALSMAGAZINETRAININGVIDEOS - REELSPODCASTSEVENTSSERVICESNEWSLETTERNEWSBLOGS

© CreativeCOW.net All rights are reserved.

[Top]