Menu Highlight not showing in Burnt DVD

I've built a PAL DVD in CS6, and when I do a build preview the menu button highlights show fine, however when I burn the DVD, the button highlights don't show at all. I've tried DVD players, computers and gaming consoles and none of them work.

The menu is a AE file running in loop with a video playing, and the buttons were generated using photoshop and the Library. I've done a project using the same settings 2 months ago and it works fine. I've tried using a new project file and building again but still no luck. Any suggestions as to what I can do?