| Jib recommendations
• | | | |
 | Jib recommendations
by stu aull on Mar 27, 2005 at 9:11:46 pm |
Looking at buying a decent, under 2K$ jib. My problem is I am in Alaska and there is no opportunity to "test drive" before I buy! The Camera package with tripod head is about 30lbs. Portability is important. I am thinking of either the Porta-Jib Traveller by Losmandy ($2100) or the Long Valley Seven Jib Compact ($1200). Obviously, the Seven looks very attractive at nearly half the price. Both are portable, though the Traveller a bit more so. Any thoughts, pro or con on these, or am I missing another make that should be looked at??
Thanks!
Stu Aull
Alaska
| | | | |
• | | | |  | Re: Jib recommendations by Frank Otto on Mar 28, 2005 at 4:10:46 pm |
The Long Valley is a good product and if weight is a factor then I'd go with that. However, the Porta-Jib is a well built machine and will serve you well over the long run.
As usual it comes down to price, weight and features, like bearings instead of sleaves on all pivot points, adjustable arm length and geometry and adaptability. Long term and ruggedness, I'd go with the Porta-Jib.
Cheers,
Frank Otto
| | | | |
• | | | |  | Re: Jib recommendations by stu aull on Mar 29, 2005 at 4:15:28 am |
Thanks Frank!
other thoughts? sounds like these are the only 2 jibs to look at....??
Stu Aull
| | | | |
• • | | | |  | Re: Jib recommendations by Frank Otto on Mar 29, 2005 at 4:23:49 pm |
I have an ezfx jib. Price-wise, it's a good value, and as we use it once or twice a quarter it doesn't get a lot of wear. That's good, since the pivot points on the arm are all nut-washer-bolt and sleave type...no bearings, and the locking mechanisim doesn't really lock all that well. The monitor bracket is nice.
It also doesn't have any way of adjusting the pantograph like the Porta-Jib does, and requires constant tighting of all the pivot bolts.
It does have a small mass for storage and hangs nicely on our grip cart. We bought it becasue it can handle a broadcast camera and mini-prompter without stressing the arm and it wasn't going to be a daily use piece of gear.
Cheers,
Frank Otto
| | | | |
• | | | |  | Re: Jib recommendations by stu aull on Mar 29, 2005 at 9:25:51 pm |
Thanks Frank-
I think, from your description, I want something a bit more refined. i plan to use it quite a bit, so the extra features and operational flexibility will be useful. many thanks!!
Stu Aull
| | | | |
• • | | | |  | Re: Jib recommendations by stu aull on Mar 29, 2005 at 10:59:57 pm |
Hi john-
checked out the site - Thanks!
I have sent an inquiry about prices... which one did YOU buy? Any particular features unique to it that attracted you??
Thanks
Stu Aull
| | | | |
• | | | |  | Re: Jib recommendations by stu aull on Mar 30, 2005 at 1:45:48 am |
John-
Cinekinetic no longer sells jibs!! They just emailed me to tell me-
So its looking like either:
Long Valley's 7-jib
or Porta-jibs Traveller
Any users out there who can help with these??
| | | | |
• | | | |  | Re: Jib recommendations by Mitch Gross on Mar 30, 2005 at 5:03:39 am |
The Porta-jib is more substantial and smoother in operation than the Seven. I've used both (and the EZFX as well) and whole-heartedly reccomend the Porta-Jib. I have one of the original Porta-jibs (standard, not the Traveller) and it has served me well after 10 solid years of abuse. I've weighed it down way, way more than it's rated for and have even seen IMAX cameras on them and never a problem. The Seven is solid but simple. It's not as smooth either; starts and stops can have a bit of "stiction" to them. I've used the Traveller as well and it worked well, but I like having the greater beef of the bigger jib for myself.
Look at the Trovatto jibs as well, if he still makes them. There's a reason that Porta-Jib has been around so long.
Mitch
| | | | |
• | | | |  | Re: Jib recommendations by Frank Otto on Mar 31, 2005 at 3:34:32 pm |
I have worked with all three as well and the Porta-Jib is far and away the best of the trio. For us, it was a matter of price and useage AND corporate spending practices that we purchased the ezfx unit.
Mitch points out the issues with the Seven...those problems aren't as bad in the ezfx and are not an issue at all with the Porta-Jib. But, as in all situations, you buy what you can afford that will do the job with as little problems and maintanance as possible.
Cheers,
Frank Otto
| | | | |
• | | | |  | Re: Jib recommendations by stu aull on Mar 31, 2005 at 7:19:01 pm |
Thanks you Frank-
obviously it would be fabulous to actually TRY these rigs out. It seems unanimous that the porta-Jib is a fine product certainly the best of this group; I am just trying to look at it from a value-for $ stand point now. Is it TWICE as good as the 7 Jib or the EZFX ($2300 vs $1300)? The expandability of the EZFX makes it more appealing than the 7, and it has a 30-day return guarantee - so it looks to be the best choice.
Thanks all for input-
kind regards
Stu Aull
| | | | |
• | | | |  | Re: Jib recommendations by stu aull on Apr 12, 2005 at 9:21:12 am |
Well - thanks for the input everyone. I can't believe some magazine hasn't done a side-by-side of these jibs!! (hint-hint) Anyway - I bought the EZFX after talking with the very helpful owner, Kevin there, and it arrived today. I have not yet used it but I have to say the apparent quality of construction is amazing. It was the cheapest one of the group - NOT my main reason for buying it, but it is beautifully assembled, with nice heavy duty attachments, clean welds, beautiful crackle-coat paint, etc. And seems to have some very nicely thought-out features, some surprisingly simple in their execution (like the spring clips that hold the weights in place, or the reversible head bowl). The down side, which I am sure almost all these rigs suffered from, is weight and size. Its 51" long without the bowl attached (+8") so it will be trickier to transport. But they did have a smaller (read: shorter jib arm) model, but I wanted the reach, so... Weight is 31lbs, which is about high/average. And to top it off they offer a 30-day-money back guarantee, so I really couldn't go wrong...
regards
Stu Aull
| | | | |
| |
|