" I would assume that the average BR on a CBR would be what you set it? "
One would assume, but I've read many reports from people who say a file encoded with Compressor is larger than one encoded witb Bitvice at the "same" bitrate. Your experience only validates Compressor's odd bitrate settings.
As for your needs: can you actually see a difference in quality between say 6Mbps CBR and 8Mbps? I doubt it, and if you can't, then use the lower bitrate for better compatiblilty if you will be distributing on DVD-R. If you do decide to continue with 8Mbps, then just use CBR: it makes little sense to use a VBR with a target of 8, unless you make the peak bitrate something like 9.5, which is not recommended.
Bob Hudson
Consultant & Writer
Video, DVD and
Multimedia Production
Overland Park, Kansas USA
http://www.bobhudson.com/