Bruno said:
"As for the "DVCAM/DV/DVCPRO25 over uncompressed" debate, I still maintain that it is much easier to attain good quality in graphics, titles and compositing by going 2:1 or better (even uncompressed) than going over FW. The DV codec just isn't there when we talk about those needs. And yes there are justifications for shooting on D35 w/DSR-1 back instead of shooting on D35 w/DigiBeta back. Postproduction is much cheaper for a lot of people who don't require Digibeta at all and DVCAM is better than BetaSP as far as I'm concerned (Isn't it Adam Wilt who said that?)"
I think you're correct (across the board) on this...
Mitch
Mitch Ives
Insight Productions Corp.
mitch@insightproductions.com
http://www.insightproductions.com